"

1 Chapter One: Sports Feminism

Section One: The Fundamentals

A) What do we know about sport? What are common assumptions we make about sport and society? 

Exercise 1: Before we go any further, I want you to take a moment and complete the phrases below:

Sport builds character.

Sport provides opportunities for social mobility.

Sport encourages teamwork and unity.

Sport reflects values and social norms.

Sport transcends politics

Sport speaks a universal language.

Sport is a measure of individual merit.

While these statements might be true on one level, on another, they do not align with many people’s experience of sport, which brings us to our first class discussion forum.
 Exercise 2: Padlet response
 Speculate on why some of the statements/assumptions above might be untrue for some people or from a certain perspective. Is there anything your peers noted that surprised you? Comment on this as well.
 [type below or paste in a screenshot of your padlet participation] 

While I believe that sports can build character in a positive way, I also recognize that they can shape character negatively in certain instances. For example, most of us can agree that being part of a sports team helps develop valuable teamwork skills, which is a clear positive. However, it’s less commonly discussed how being on a sports team can foster unhealthy habits, such as constant comparison to teammates or an excessive drive to outperform others. These behaviors can lead to feelings of inadequacy or pressure, which may negatively impact one’s enjoyment and overall relationship with the sport.

A real-life example is Simone Biles, the renowned gymnast. On the positive side, Simone Biles exemplifies how sports can build character through resilience, hard work, and perseverance. Her dedication to gymnastics has made her the most decorated gymnast in history, and she often speaks about how her sport has taught her discipline and the importance of teamwork. However, Simone’s experiences also highlight the negative side of sports. Leading up to the 2021 Tokyo Olympics, she faced immense pressure to perform at an elite level, which led to mental health struggles. She famously withdrew from several events, citing a condition called “the twisties,” where gymnasts lose spatial awareness. Simone’s decision to prioritize her mental health over competing opened up a larger conversation about the negative pressures in competitive sports, such as the constant drive for perfection and comparison to others, which can lead to burnout and feelings of inadequacy.

A person commented about internal motivation which aligns closely with my perspective on how sports can build both positive and negative character traits. I agree that if a child is only participating in sports because of parental pressure, without genuine interest or engagement, it’s less likely they’ll experience personal growth. Instead, they might focus on negative aspects, like feeling forced or inadequate, which can hinder character development. This ties into my point about how competition and comparison within sports can sometimes foster negative traits. In both cases, whether it’s lack of motivation or unhealthy comparisons, the environment can impact how someone experiences sports and whether it contributes to their growth.

Exercise 3: Notebook prompt

What are some other metanarratives about sport that you are familiar with? Find an image or video clip or draw something yourself that captures this idea…

So what? Why does any of this matter?  Does it matter? As something we grow up with – live with – play through – we don’t often interrogate the meanings of sport, and perhaps we don’t want to.

But being aware of these assumptions and metanarratives is especially important, I would argue, because of the centrality of sport to our everyday lives, the role that sport plays in shaping our childhood and worldviews and….. [finish that thought] 

Sport is often framed as a key contributor to health and wellness, viewed primarily as a way to keep our bodies fit and healthy. However, this metanarrative is rarely questioned. While sport can indeed promote physical fitness and mental well-being, it also carries significant risks. For instance, sustaining a concussion during gymnastics can leave someone with lasting trauma, not only physically but also emotionally, potentially altering their relationship with the sport and detracting from their overall health. This becomes even more important when considering the cultural and social structures surrounding sport. As Scraton and Flintoff argue, sport is deeply embedded within societal power dynamics and often reinforces dominant ideologies, such as competitiveness, achievement, and perfection. These ideals can exacerbate risks by creating environments where athletes feel pressured to prioritize performance over their well-being, even at the expense of their health. For example, young gymnasts may continue to train and compete despite injuries due to societal and institutional expectations around success and resilience. These pressures not only challenge the simplistic notion that sport is inherently beneficial but also expose how its underlying structures can perpetuate harm. So, why does this matter? It matters because sport shapes our childhood experiences, influences our worldviews, and informs our understanding of health and success. Yet, as Scraton and Flintoff suggest, the cultural glorification of sport often masks its complexities and potential for harm. By critically examining this narrative, we can better address issues of power, inequality, and risk within sport, fostering a more inclusive and realistic approach. This shift would prioritize safety, well-being, and long-term health over performance at all costs, ensuring sport truly contributes to individual and collective wellness.

 

B) What is social justice?

Exercise 4: Padlet Prompt 

Think back to the last section and try to look at some of the ideas we discussed differently. How might sport and social justice actually co-exist?

Record any images, video clips, or gifs you added to the padlet and identify a point of intersection between sport and social justice (can be an issue or a barrier or a debate or something you would like to explore in more depth in this course) . Screenshot or paste in your response below.

The intersection of sport and society is evident in issues of equity and representation. For example, societal norms often push girls toward sports like dance, ringette, or volleyball while discouraging their participation in full-contact sports like judo, hockey, or rugby—sports that are traditionally viewed as male-dominated. Similarly, boys who choose sports like gymnastics often face ridicule or have their masculinity questioned, revealing how deeply ingrained gender stereotypes are in the world of sport. A powerful example of challenging these norms is Ilona Maher, an advocate for breaking gender barriers in sports. As a professional rugby player, she not only represents women in a male-dominated field but also embraces and celebrates the athletic build her sport has given her. Her message that “it’s okay for girls to have big arms and wide shoulders” empowers girls to defy traditional standards of femininity and pursue their passions unapologetically. By breaking these stereotypes, Maher inspires a more inclusive and equitable view of what sports can and should be for all genders.

C) Social Justice Reading 

  (note: this activity is optional!)

D) KINESIOLOGY AND SOCIAL JUSTICE

Exercise 5: 

Exercise 6:

What are the implications of bodies-at-risk discourse and the refusal to understand the health gap from a social justice perspective, according to the authors of this article?

Harrison, Azzarito, and Hodge argue that the bodies-at-risk discourse and the failure to understand the health gap through a social justice lens have important implications. By framing health as a personal responsibility, this discourse overlooks the structural factors—like poverty, discrimination, and access to resources—that significantly influence health outcomes. This individualistic approach reinforces existing inequalities, as it fails to consider the broader social determinants of health and primarily benefits those in privileged positions, leaving marginalized groups behind. Moreover, the commodification of health positions it as a marketable product, with access to better health outcomes often determined by financial means. This only deepens health disparities between those who can afford these resources and those who cannot. The focus on personal responsibility also leads to stigmatization, particularly for marginalized individuals who face greater barriers to achieving societal health standards. Ultimately, by ignoring these systemic issues, this approach prevents meaningful solutions that could address the root causes of health inequalities.

Section Two: Sport Feminism

Exercise 7: Notebook Prompt

What is feminism?  What does it mean to you? Choose one of the images below and explain how it captures your understanding of feminism (or find one that does speak to you and paste this into your pressbook with an explanation of why it matters to you.

Feminism is an objective term, yet it can hold different meanings for different people. To me, feminism represents the pursuit of equal rights between men and women, as well as the acknowledgment by men that they are not inherently superior to women. The image I chose to represent my understanding of feminism is a man wearing a shirt that says, “This is what a feminist looks like.” This image resonates with me because it emphasizes that feminism is not solely about women advocating for other women. It also involves men standing up for women’s rights and recognizing the importance of gender equality. This broader, inclusive perspective on feminism is essential for fostering a society where equality is valued and actively supported by all genders.

A real-life example that aligns with this context is the “HeForShe” campaign launched by UN Women. This initiative invites men to actively participate in the pursuit of gender equality, recognizing that feminism is not just a women’s movement but a collective effort. In 2014, actor Emma Watson, a UN Women Goodwill Ambassador, gave a powerful speech at the United Nations to launch the campaign. She emphasized that feminism is about achieving equality and that men must be allies in this process. She called on men to stand alongside women, challenging stereotypes and societal norms that perpetuate inequality. One notable example of this in practice is Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who publicly identifies as a feminist and consistently advocates for gender equality. He famously stated, “Because it’s 2015,” when asked why he appointed a gender-balanced cabinet. His actions reflect the belief that feminism involves men actively supporting and promoting equality, which is in line with the message conveyed by the image of a man wearing a shirt that says, “This is what a feminist looks like.”

Exercise 8: Notes Prompt (optional)

NB: Cornell notes is a great resource that teaches effective notetaking. Unfortunately, our system can’t save notes taken in the H5P app, so this is fully optional.

Exercise 9: Crossword Activity 

  1. this is seen as the main focus of liberal feminism – reform
  2. what word do the authors use to describe dominant sociological approaches to sport – malestream
  3. a central concern of both Marxist and socialist feminism – capitalism
  4. first name of major black woman tennis star – serena
  5. one of the aspects of radical feminist thought that is regularly criticized – essentialism
  6. one of the central theories of gender developed by poststructuralist feminist philosopher, Judith Butler – performativity
  7. also a concern of liberal feminist sport research in respect to decision-making and leadership position – underrepresentation
  8. differences in female sports participation is a product of this practice – socialization
  9. radical feminists argue that “women’s involvement in sport is controlled and restricted through their clothing” and the expectation they will present this kind of image – heterosexy
  10. One of the criticisms leveled against poststructural and queer theory for tendencies to emphasize “difference and thus lose the notion of women’s shared experiences in relation to gender” – relativism
  11. identified by the authors as a central concern of postcolonial theorizing about identify – fluidity
  12. the last name of a prominent radical feminist named in the article – rich
  13. this is seen as the result of taking whiteness as a taken for granted central position that relegates blackness to “otherness” – invisibility

Exercise 10:  Padlet Prompt

Create your own word cloud including all of the important terms and concepts covered in the article that were not included in the crossword activity! (Record or screenshot your response below).

Culture, patriarchy, gender, justice, sport, challenges, barriers, advocacy, discrimination, feminism, race, ethnicity, Marxist, Socialist, heterosexuality, heterosexy, bodies, opression, inclusion, black, white, diversity, capitalism, liberal, masculanity, queer, dominance, inequality, socialization, emotionality, equality, power, access

Exercise 11: Padlet Discussion Prompt (optional) 
The illustration featured in this padlet (of a basketball with the word “women’s” eclipsing a basketball bearing the word “men’s” at the time of the solar eclipse) ran last year in a Philadelphia newspaper piece about how athletes like Angel Reese and Caitlin Clark were generating unprecedented enthusiasm for women’s sport. Do you feel the landscape is changing? Do people care about women’s sport?

The illustration highlights an important cultural shift in the perception of women’s sports, and I do believe the landscape is changing. Athletes like Angel Reese and Caitlin Clark have brought unprecedented attention to women’s sports, not just through their exceptional talent but also through the intense media coverage and public engagement they’ve garnered. This increased visibility is reshaping attitudes and challenging traditional biases that have long relegated women’s sports to the sidelines. As Wetherly, Watson, and Long emphasize in Sport, Leisure and Social Justice, women’s sports have historically been marginalized due to structural inequalities embedded in societal and institutional frameworks. They discuss how systemic barriers, such as unequal funding, lack of media representation, and deeply ingrained gender norms, have hindered progress. However, they also point to the significance of moments that challenge these inequities, citing examples like the 2015 Women’s World Cup. That tournament set attendance and viewership records, demonstrating the potential for women’s sports to captivate global audiences when adequately promoted and supported. Today, we see similar patterns in the success of athletes like Reese and Clark, whose performances in the NCAA Women’s Basketball Tournament have drawn record-breaking viewership. While progress is evident, disparities in media coverage, funding, and attendance between men’s and women’s sports persist. For instance, Sport, Leisure and Social Justice highlights how even when women’s sports receive media attention, the narratives often focus on appearance or personality rather than athletic achievement, reinforcing gendered stereotypes. However, growing fan bases, record-breaking viewership, and increased sponsorships for women’s sports suggest that more people do care. Events like the Women’s World Cup and the NCAA Women’s Basketball Tournament have proven that women’s sports can generate significant enthusiasm and profitability when given the platform and respect they deserve. By addressing structural inequities and reframing narratives, we can further accelerate this cultural shift and ensure that women’s sports continue to thrive.

License

Icon for the Public Domain license

This work (Gender, Sport, and Social Justice by Kelly McGuire) is free of known copyright restrictions.