Historical or Biographical Critical Lens
Author-Based/Historical Criticism
Though generally author-based and historical criticism are seen as two different categories, for the purpose of simplicity, we are going to combine them together in this text. An author-based/historical critical lens is focused on uncovering the person of the author in a text. Since this text focuses on discovering the voices of women through history, this approach can be very useful in helping us to get to know the women behind the texts we read.
When looking through this ‘lens,’ our goal is to find out as much as possible about the author and their life and context. We might read a biography on the author or read about the time in history in which they lived. Learning about the author’s life and where and when they lived can tell us a lot about a text, and vice versa.
For example, many students have trouble with Emily Dickinson’s poems. They don’t seem to make sense with their strange punctuation and fixation on death. But, as we investigate her life, we find that she didn’t intend for her poetry to ever be read. In fact, her poems are like a journal that she kept of her thoughts and experiences. Further, discovering that she lived close to the front lines of the Civil War helps us to make sense of her preoccupation with death.
Watch It: What is Historical Criticism
Watch What is historical criticism (4:30 minutes) on YouTube
Video source: Nance, T. [Tim Nance]. (2015, March 2). What is historical criticism? [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/SMxkN81QhKw
What to look for:
- Who? Who is/was the author? Who is their family? What are the author’s core values/beliefs?
- What? What is the text about? How does that topic connect with the author’s experiences or the author’s historical context?
- When? When did the author live? What significant events happened? What was life like? How is the time period significant?
- Where? Where did the author live? How is that location significant?
- Why? Why did the author write? Do we know? Was the work in response to something that happened in the author’s life or in history?
Attribution & References
Except where otherwise noted, this chapter is adapted from “Reading Through a Critical Lens” In Say Her Name: Discovering Women’s Voices in History by Dr. Karen Palmer, licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. /Adaptations include removal of content referring to Feminist theory including text and videos.