"

3 Module 3: Why is the Earth’s Climate Changing?

In this module, we address the question “Why is the earth’s climate changing?” The short answer is: recent climate warming is the result of human activities. When you extend your curiosity deeper and continue to ask why, you find more layers to this answer. The behaviour of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, ice core records, the global energy balance, and the carbon cycle teach us how human activities are leading to warming.  Learning about natural laws teaches us about reciprocity with earth, and how environmental dispossession and colonialism have disrupted this reciprocity.

If you are using this module in isolation, consider including the introductory video from module 1.

The module begins with an introductory video to why the climate is changing, as well as several key questions a student might be asking when learning about why the climate is changing. These questions are:

  • How do we know that increasing the concentration of carbon dioxide int he atmosphere will cause temperatures to warm?
  • How do we know that the increases in carbon dioxide observed isn’t just natural variations in Earth’s climate system?
  • How do we know that it is human activities that are causing carbon dioxide to increase?

Students are asked to read one or two of the stories below, and reflect on what they’ve learned from them.

“How the Chipmunk got its Stripes: The Origin of Sickness and Cures.” In Murdoch, I. & Belcourt, C. (2019). The Trail of Nenabooszhoo: and other Creation Stories. Kegedonce Press. pp. 105-112.

“All our Relations”. In Simpson, L. (2013). The Gift is in the Making. Portage & Main Press. pp 19-22.

Recommendation: Help students access these or other stories.

Reach out to a librarian or copyright specialist to include these book excerpts or other stories of your choosing.

 

Learning Outcomes

  • Reflect on changes in Earth’s climate in your lifetime and that of your parents and grandparents.
  • Recall the importance of the ice core data and Indigenous Knowledge to understanding present day climate change.
  • Illustrate and summarize the global energy balance and the carbon cycle.
  • Differentiate between the natural and anthropogenic greenhouse effect.
  • Distinguish positive and negative climate feedbacks and explain how they influence climate change.
  • Explore the role of colonialism in the climate crisis.
  • Illustrate how Indigenous legal traditions can inform environment and resource management.

 

Lesson 1: Lessons about the past teach us about climate change theory

In this interactive lesson, students will take a closer look at the incredible sources of data that teach us how the climate change we are experiencing today is different from changes in the past. Students will also learn about climate feedbacks, which have been operating throughout earth’s history, and still impact climate today.

Students complete a StoryMap called “Lessons from the Past”. This lesson looks at what we can learn from oral storytelling and ice core records about the past, and also introduces students to climate feedbacks.

 

Recommendation: Decide on and communicate your “Must Knows”

This course is created for multiple disciplines, but not all information included will be of equal importance in your discipline. For example, in our 2nd year Climate Change course, which is open to all students at Western University, stable isotope science is outside of the learning outcomes for the course. However, experience tells us that for some students, accepting stable isotope science (which is a key to reconstructing past temperatures, among other climate variables) at face value is hard to do.
So, the StoryMap includes an optional section for students who wish to know more about stable isotope records. Stable isotope records from ice cores and marine sediment cores are critical evidence for our understanding of past climates, and just how abnormal current climate changes are. This is our way of satisfying the curiosity of students who have unanswered questions about how we can get temperature reconstructions going back 800,000 years or more without requiring all students to be able to explain stable isotope science.
You may decide to take a similar approach with other aspects of the course, including them in a “Want to Know More” optional category so that curious students can learn more without the pressure of having that knowledge assessed.

Lesson 2: The Greenhouse Effect and the Role of the Earth’s Atmosphere in the Earth’s Energy Balance

The greenhouse effect is now a term nearly everyone knows, but many people have difficulty explaining how it works.  This lesson introduces students to the greenhouse effect (which is natural, and exists on other planets too!) and the enhanced greenhouse effect, which is behind the climate crisis.

In this lesson, students will

  • Watch the video on the greenhouse effect and the earth’s atmosphere
  • Complete practice questions
  • Watch a video on Earth’s natural greenhouse effect.

Lesson 3: The Earth’s Energy Balance

In this lesson we examine how an enhanced greenhouse effect changes the Earth’s energy balance, which leads to a warming planet. This lesson is critical to understanding how increasing greenhouse gases, such as CO2, causes an increase in Earth’s temperature.

In this lesson, students will complete a StoryMap called “Earth’s Energy Balance and Climate Change”.

Lesson 4: The Carbon cycle and connections to the earth’s climate

In the last lesson students learned how increasing greenhouse gases in the atmosphere can lead to a warming planet. Where do greenhouse gases come from and why are they increasing? In this lesson students will learn about the carbon cycle, which will illustrate where one of the most important greenhouse gases is stored and how it is cycled between the Earth’s spheres.

Why are we talking about the carbon cycle? Presently, the greenhouse gas of most concern is carbon dioxide (CO2). The importance of a given greenhouse gas is dependent on three things that we will explore more in the next lesson. These are the concentration of the gas in the atmosphere, how effective the gas molecules are at absorbing infrared radiation and the length of time the molecules can remain in the atmosphere. Carbon dioxide is of most concern because it has the highest atmospheric concentration of the greenhouse gases and it persists in the atmosphere for a long time (years to millennia). Students will explore this more in the next module, but in this lesson we will learn about how CO2 ends up in the atmosphere naturally and how humans have altered the carbon cycle to rapidly increase the atmospheric  concentration of CO2.

After this lesson students will know how and why the Earth is warming. But knowing about something doesn’t always make it tangible. To help you connect with our changing world, students participate in a graded activity to interview someone from a different generation about their experiences of the world and the changes that they have observed.

In this lesson, students will:

  • Watch a video “Introducing the Earth’s Carbon Cycle”
  • Watch a video “Ocean and Geologic Exchange of Carbon”
  • Answer practice questions about the videos.

Graded Activity: Intergenerational Interview

In this graded activity, students are asked to interview someone from a different generation than you who has observed first-hand the significant changes that have occurred over 50+ years.  The lesson provides example questions and an example intergenerational interview to inspire students. Students are asked to follow up with the answers given with their own reflection.

Recommendation: Adjust this graded activity to meet the needs of your course.

The key outcome for this activity is for students to connect intergenerationally with someone and find out what they have observed in their life, what they are connected to, and what they care about.

This assessment has many opportunities for adjustment to align best with your course. For example, consider:

  • Asking your journalism students to come up with their own questions or submit an edited version of the video for assessment
  • Asking your agricultural science students to interview a current or retired farmer
  • Asking your history students to connect what they’ve learned about someone’s life with local records
  • Asking your geography or earth science students to find temperature data relevant to the land and time frame mentioned by their interviewee
  • Asking your art students to find a way to represent the changes they’ve heard about in art form. Example.

For any of these activities, give your students an opportunity to connect about what they learned in an in-class discussion or in a small forum or chat group.

Lesson 5: Colonialism Caused Climate Change

The terms colonialism, settler colonialism, and capitalism have been mentioned numerous times throughout the modules, but in Lesson 5, students take a deeper look into the consequences and impacts of these systems, their oppressive nature towards Indigenous Peoples and ways of life, but also the harm they cause to all peoples and life via their direct impacts on the climate. Students will begin to understand the root socio-economic causes of climate change, and the importance of Indigenous governance and land stewardship. Indigenous peoples are intimately connected to the land, so what happens when oppressive systems try to sever their connection to their human and non-human kin? The climate crisis.

In this lesson students will:

  • Watch the video “Colonialism caused Climate change”
  • Complete a reflection on Environmental Dispossession and Climate Change

The video “Colonialism caused Climate Change” features Māori scholar Dr. Lewis Williams, who shares expertise on Intergenerational Resilience, Climate change, and decolonization.

Recommendation: Ask students to go deeper

We recognize that many students in a number of disciplines are only now being introduced to concepts like colonialism, environmental dispossession, and socio-economic causes of climate change. Therefore, we are providing students a chance for an initial reflection on what they have learned about colonialism and climate change. In your discipline, students may be ready to go deeper with their reflection, and you could use this as an introduction to a more involved reflection or short response paper, using the example of environmental dispossession provided.

 

License

Connecting For Climate Change Action - Facilitator's Guide Copyright © by Beth Hundey; Katrina Moser; Sara Mai Chitty; and Serena Mendizábal. All Rights Reserved.