79 Analyzing Taylor Swift’s “Midnights” Fans on Social Media
Introduction:
When Taylor Swift surprise dropped her tenth studio album, “Midnights,” on October 21, 2022, it sparked an immediate flurry of impassioned reactions from her loyal fanbase. In the r/TaylorSwift subreddit, with over 1.3 million members, fans congregated to obsessively analyze, celebrate, and defend Swift’s latest confessional pop opus. In this paper, I analyze a selection of r/TaylorSwift discussion threads and user-created content in the two months following the “Midnights” release to explore the affective investments fuelling participatory audience engagement. My analysis suggests that Swift’s predominantly young, female fanbase leverages the affordances of Reddit’s platform to assert their cultural power as tastemakers, mount defences against the artist’s detractors, and engage in identity exploration through dissecting Swift’s intimate lyrics.
I have chosen to focus specifically on r/TaylorSwift as it represents a dedicated group of super-fans within the broader Swift fandom. As a long running subreddit with established community norms, it offers rich insight into audience practices. By narrowing the analytical lens to output generated in the aftermath of this specific album drop over a condensed period, we can achieve an in-depth understanding of the passions and investments currently motivating participation. My analysis interweaves specific evidence of enunciative productivity with connections to key concepts around gendered fandoms, affect theory, and participatory culture. Ultimately, I argue that the Midnights-focused r/TaylorSwift discussions highlight how audiences leverage digital platforms to affirm personal resonance with pop culture artefacts and transcend their marginalized tastes through collective meaning-making and grassroots promotion.
- Description of Audience and Platform:
With over 1.3 million members, the r/TaylorSwift subreddit stands as one of Reddit’s most vibrant fan communities centered around a music artist (Forslund, 2023). Reddit is an online platform organized around topic-specific forums dubbed “subreddits” where users share content and discussions related to particular areas of interest. Given Taylor Swift’s status as one of the world’s biggest pop stars with an especially passionate global fanbase, the r/TaylorSwift subreddit facilitates highly engaged participatory audience behaviours between her devoted followers.
As Carroll (2023) highlights, while music fandoms have transitioned substantially into online spaces, these digital fan cultures retain close ties to longstanding practices of fan community building and identity expression. Features like Reddit that allow niche groups to gather through shared musical passions enable both individual and collective meaning-making. An examination of subscriber interactions on r/TaylorSwift in response to Swift’s album releases offers rich insights into contemporary pop fandoms.
Demographic Details:
As Galloway’s analysis of Taylor Swift fan podcast cultures outlines, her supporters represent a diverse array of ages, gender identities and geographic locations (Galloway, 2022). However, a predominant segment of Swift’s fanbase skews female, millennial and American. Observation of posting habits and references on r/TaylorSwift tend to reflect these key demographics. For instance, threads often assume familiarity with recent US sociopolitical debates that intersect with Swift’s public advocacy around issues like LGBTQ+ rights. And while international fans certainly maintain a presence, discussions frequently center American cultural perspectives and events like annual Coachella performances or Met Gala appearances.
That said, the global accessibility of Reddit means the subreddit also demonstrates the star’s truly global resonance. As Yahr (2022) notes in profiling Swift’s cultural impact over the past year, 2022 marked the first time she “topped charts in nearly 100 countries” with a project simultaneously, reflecting unprecedented international domination only bolstered by her online fandom networks.
Platform Parameters:
In their analysis of learning processes in Taylor Swift online affinity spaces, Magliocca (2023) notes these forums’ decentralized, non-hierarchical nature distinguishes them from more rigidly moderated official fan-club platforms. Accordingly, the flow of dialogue within r/TaylorSwift frequently branches across myriad autonomous threads rather than conforming to focused themes or perspectives. Moreover, the platforms upvote and downvote functionality means crowd-sourced moderation allows content considered off-topic or inappropriate to get downvoted into oblivion instead of being deleted outright.
These structural affordances profoundly shape participant interactions and information flows. For instance, the previously noted thread questioning why Swift’s latest album rollout seemed atypically low-profile earned thousands of upvotes for its perceived relevance and ability to spark speculation. Yet the minority critique thread doubting the new album’s quality (mr_struggle2, 2022) earned far more downvotes than supportive takes likely thanks to impassioned fans aversion to any criticism of their idol.
Through these complex modulatory dynamics and shepherding of opinions and agendas, the parameters and variances of permissible discourse becomes largely community led. Secret sessions with Swift herself get blessed as official verified encounters, while supposed leaks or rumours face intense scrutiny. What emerges is a largely self-regulating, decentralized network with information flows and norms navigated through crowd-aggregated judgments rather than top-down oversight.
III. Evidence of Audience Engagement:
The Taylor Swift subreddit community demonstrated intense engagement and enunciative productivity in response to the October 2022 “Midnights” album release. Analysis of comments and discussion threads in the week following unveiling of this highly anticipated project reveals multifaceted participation centered on shared bonds over the music and performer. From lyric analysis to creative works to personal reflections, subreddit subscribers enacted passionate fandom rooted in affective affinity with Swift as an icon of self-relatable vulnerability.
Thematic Breakdown:
In transcripts of an academic symposium analyzing transitivity in Swift song lyrics, researchers highlight recurring thematic fascinations that resonate deeply amongst the star’s followers (Max et al, 2023). Notably, these include amplifications of romantic intensities, expressions of defiance and liberation from oppression, and self-knowing reflections on public identity. Discussions on the “Midnights” release prominently incorporated each of these motifs across creative tangents.
For instance, multiple threads fixated on deciphering coded lyrics alluding to Swift’s dating life and sexuality with fans debating everything from queer readings to theories she may have married partner Joe Alwyn in secret (Forslund, 2023). These romantic real-life fan fictional conjurings demonstrate core investments in the singer as a confidante figure expressing familiar relationship tribulations.
Equally, fans enthusiastically praised tracks like “Anti-Hero” and “Karma” for showcasing Swift’s insecurities and demonstrations of “self-awareness about her own flaws but told beautifully through her song writing” (z-side reviews, 2022). Vulnerable introspection and triumph over adversity remains central to her ethos as fans relate to candid disclosures.
Platform Resonance:
Swift’s propensity for honestly unpacking evolutions in her self-awareness with listeners fosters an intimate para-social relationship that resonates profoundly with digitally engaged followers. A study in the Journal of Popular Music Studies examining Taylor Swift fan podcast cultures unpacks listeners investment in “working through their lived experiences alongside Swift” thanks to her airing of personal growth in-process rather than as conclusion (Galloway, 2022).
Reddit discussions reflect and extend this experience of communal meaning-making, with members bonding through shared elation, speculation, in-jokes, and earnest identification. As Senior-Muffin-6991 (2023) asked in their post ”Is Midnights anyone’s favourite album?” forum participants overwhelmingly declared the record one of their longtime favourites thanks to feeling a deeper connection to this version of Swift as a late-night over thinker akin to themselves.
Affective Investments:
Magliocca’s analysis of communication strategies activated amongst Taylor Swift fans highlights that such online collective meaning-making fosters deeper individual and group attachments via what they classify as ’embodied learning’ processes (Magliocca, 2023). Through consuming, decoding and collectively processing affect-rich texts like emotionally revealing lyrics or vivid music videos, fans feel listened to, supported and bonded with the star and each other.
Observed Reddit discourse absolutely supports such a model of para-social and inter-fan affiliations coalescing through shared impassioned reactions. One listener stated “I cried like a baby the first time I heard Sweet Nothing and still tear up sometimes” bonding with Swift’s lullaby to her baby (Z.-side’s Music Reviews, 2022). Others felt compelled to academically analyze favoured tracks like “Lavender Haze” which “perfectly encapsulates the feeling of new love” for them thanks to relatable lyrics (Max et al., 2023).
Through these manifestations, subreddit exchanges enable devotees to tangibly enact fandom, merging individual experiences with shared cultural engagements.
- Affective Dimensions:
Analysis of the passionate subreddit dialogues among Taylor Swift fans in response to her “Midnights” release reveals multifaceted affective investments supporters’ channel into her as both a public figure and conduit for self-expression. From sentimental attachments to senses of ownership over her creative works, Swift’s meta-textual candor fosters profound connections infusing fan discussions with layers of feeling. Examining directions and dimensions of expressed emotion spotlights her cultural resonance.
Defensive Fandom:
A study in the journal Celebrity Studies analyzing behaviours amongst followers of digitally engaged celebrities like Swift unpacks common ‘performative passivity’ amongst fandoms seeking to shield favoured icons from criticism (Carroll, 2023). Rather than directly chastising detractors, followers overwhelm critiques with gushing praise indirectly drowning out negative takes.
This tendency is blatantly evident across Reddit threads related to “Midnights” which brim with effusive celebration countering the minority perspectives questioning the album’s quality or cohesion (Rosenblatt, 2022). As one subscriber pronounced, “This album is a masterpiece and continues her reign” succinctly summarizing predominant perspectives from those quick to assure even modest critiques were invalid amongst true fans. The affective intensity behind this defensiveness reflects deep personal identification with Swift as a figure and what her art represents to them.
Spatial Politics:
In an auto-ethnographic account of their experiences amongst highly online Taylor Swift fandom spaces, Carroll (2023) analyzes how niche audience factions manifest complex ‘spatial politics’ dictating norms of feeling and sites of contestation. Though subcultural fragmentation allows most shared creative works to emphasize collective adulation, some domains foster heated in-group debates.
Observed “Midnights” discussions encapsulate these divergent spatial dynamics as most threads cohere around euphoric consensus with the album cementing Swift’s iconic brilliance. Yet spaces specifically dedicated to critiquing the record or its rollout strategy became counter sites witnessing rare fracture (Booth, 2018). Spatial segmentation thus contains dissent absent in the main subreddit feeds overflowing with praise. The affective flows remain overwhelmingly positive through careful boundary management. This conscious curation of shared sentiment and mourning demonstrates fans deep investments in experiencing mutual joy and validation with one another just as much as Swift herself. Their subconscious adherence to platform etiquettes reifying adulation reflects identity fusion with a collective rooted fundamentally in emotional bonds.
Para-social Co-Construction:
Communication scholars argue Taylor Swift’s strategic self-disclosures continuously expand follower investments via deepening their sense of mutual co-construction between artist and audience (Magliocca, 2023). Through digesting, decoding and collectively processing vulnerability narratives across songs, videos and media presences, fans feel bonded in intimate processes of reciprocal identity formation.
This immersive para-social entanglement emerges clearly across Reddit exchanges dotted with theories about how specific “Midnights” lyrical Easter eggs connect to Swift’s dating history or friendships, stoking speculation she sneakily fuels. As one poster notes, her penchant for leaving tantalizing gaps “is incredibly effective in getting people talking about the album” (Max et al., 2023). Ongoing co-authorship of her public narrative thus satiates follower desire for deeper integration.
The extensive theorizing and over-reading of references demonstrates the acute emotional attachment supporters feel to piecing together a mosaic understanding of Swift’s self-evolution across albums. Tracking her winding path to liberation and self-awareness becomes a mutually constructed, crowdsourced exegesis offering cathartic perspective into fans’ own journeys too.
Creativity Catalysis:
Literary analyses of Swift’s intertextual references across albums posit that alluding to existing cultural texts prompts fan intertextual production in return (Z.-side’s Music Reviews, 2022). Just as she samples lyric snippets from 1950s classics on “Midnights,” remixing old musical touchstones to express modern emotional truths, fans feel compelled to engage in creative play channeling their own perspectives through the prism of her works.
This proliferative dynamic explains the array of art, memes, gifs and discussions flooding Reddit unpacking resonances between the album and supporters’ self-conceptions. As Forslund’s (2023) study of queer readings notes, Swift’s lyrical ambiguity fosters fertile imaginative terrain for fans to graft deeper personal meanings. Through seeming to co-create textual possibilities purposely unresolved, she activates impassioned creativity and connections.
The cascading flow of fan remixes, podcasts, TikTok’s and forum exchanges thus constitute a reciprocal engagement ecosystem tied together by elective affinities. Supporters publicly perform bonded allegiance with Swift and each other by riffing the album much as she riffs existing cultural materials. This interplay spotlights her cultural ubiquity while satiating follower desires for belonging. Together they manifest an ongoing co-constructive retelling.
- Connections to Key Concepts:
Analysis of the passionate subreddit dialogues among Taylor Swift fans in response to her “Midnights” release reveals multifaceted participatory engagement and meaning-making practices rooted in longtime fan cultural traditions. By assessing observed audience activities against relevant scholarship, we can situate behaviours within three key frameworks – participatory culture, gendered fandoms, and platform vernaculars.
In his seminal writings on participatory culture, Jenkins defines key hallmarks including affiliations within social connections, expressions via productive creativity, collaborative problem solving, and circulations of media content (Jenkins, 2012). Across all these measures, Reddit activities in the aftermath of Swift unveiling new material demonstrates substantial participation. Fans affiliate via shared discourse, creative works, and debates. They collaboratively solve interpretive puzzles posed by lyrical hints and clues. And they circulate external links, images and videos expanding the album’s cultural presence.
Moreover, these participatory behaviours map neatly onto Jenkins’ proposal of fans asserting themselves as “readers who appropriate popular texts and reread them in a fashion that serves different interests” (Jenkins, 2012, p. 34). Through threads sharing favourite tracks or personal reactions, supporters re-contextualize Midnights into frameworks meaningful for their own identities or perspectives. User reviews emphasizing relatability reorient lyrics around lived experiences. Queer interpretations situate songs as romantic revelations rather than following assumed cis heteronormativity (Buchanan, 2023). And marginalized groups like neurodivergent listeners declare feeling seen by the album’s candidness about struggles like anxiety.
As Booth (2018) summarizes, “Participatory culture supports collaborative meaning-making practices and peer-to-peer learning” (p. 14). So while commercial dimensions undoubtedly factor given Swift’s stature as a best-selling superstar, fans participatory explorations of resonance tap aesthetic potentials beyond mainstream marketing frames. Through collaborative meaning-making, subreddit members delve into subcultural vocabularies and diverse self-expressions only implemented thanks to Swift’s initially open-ended invitation.
As much scholarship on music cultures outlines, pop music frequently sees construction of highly gendered ontologies positioning male performers and creators as serious auteurs while female artists become framed through lenses of emotional intimacy (Buchanan, 2023). Critical dismissal or insincere readings of commercial female pop thus emerge less from sonic elements than gendered paradigms.
Observed subreddit commentary seems predicated precisely against resisting such paradigms through seriously and collectively elevating feminine-coded perspectives. Reactions passionately defend Swift’s brilliance against charges of frivolity by underscoring her artistry and work ethic. And fan theories striving to situate autobiographical dimensions from a place of empathy similarly foreground gender socialization experiences shaping observed artistic choices. As one fan proposes regarding lyrical metaphors potentially hinting at disordered eating struggles: “It’s easy to see those behaviours as vain when you don’t understand that women are forced into them” (Z.-side’s Music Reviews, 2022).
Through such serious unpacking of sociocultural contexts driving Swift’s confessed insecurities and self-doubts in tracks like “Anti-Hero,” supporters counterbalance engrained cultural stratifications that might otherwise fuel trivializations of female pop star self-reflection as indulgent melodrama. Calls rejecting critiques hence act both as affective expressions of personal connection and politically loaded demands for acknowledging socio-structural conditions molding those emotions.
In Booth’s analysis, “sites like Reddit have their own evolving platform vernaculars” dictating communicative norms (2018, p. 201). Hence participatory fan activities manifest quite divergently social media to social media based on site-specific functionalities and discursive conventions. Whereas TikTok spawns condensed videos, and Twitter one-liner jokes or hot takes, Reddit’s infrastructure of threaded exchanges more naturally fosters serialized, evidence-backed conversation and debate.
This affordance explains both the platform’s appeal to impassioned music supporters inclined towards analytical exchanges, as well as shaping observable communicative patterns emphasizing rationale discourse. Posts earnestly unpacking lyrical connections adhere thanks to lengthy back-and-forths debating meanings. Opinions Marshall textual evidence and develop across cascading exchanges. Even posts self-tagged as seemingly frivolous like fan-casting Swift biopics still sustain nested discussions evidencing close consideration.
So while all pop-star fandoms undoubtedly incorporate performative behaviours announcing allegiances rather than purely critically investigating artistry, Reddit conversations frequently balance affectation with explanation thanks to platform vernaculars. One post asking, “Do you think Taylor keeps up with what fans are saying online?” demonstrates posters citing past media statements about her public awareness to support or challenge opinions (Forslund, 2023). The ensuing conversations thus sustain substantive dialogue through privileging substantiated perspectives, a useful reminder that modalities of communication remain mediated by their structural contexts.
- Conclusion:
In conclusion, analysis of Taylor Swift fan engagement on Reddit in response to her latest “Midnights” album unveils the complex interplay between individual investments and collective connections characterizing contemporary pop music fandoms. Through passionate exchanges encryption with resonance, creativity, meaning-making and grassroots promotion, the platform provided space for followers to entwine expressions of self with celebration of their favoured performer. Observational analysis of key discussions threads reveals supporters leveraging affordances to assert intricate artist-audience co-constructive bonds elevating their own marginalized positionalities while securing Swift’s profound cultural centrality.
From lyrical analysis to identity play to anti-critic defences, fans participatory activities fuse the personal with the political, the frivolous with the substantive. Their efforts spotlight Swift’s enduring talent for converting candid vulnerability into profound mass intimacy binding supporter networks through elective affinities. And their spirited exchanges similarly spotlight the persistent desire amongst even fragmented modern communities to locate shared wells of sentiment and imagination through which to transcend isolation. By taking audience engagements seriously on their own terms, we glimpse the significant role pop cultures continue providing in vital social fabrics linking selves to society.
References
ban_ana_perfect. (2022, September 16). The making of Midnights🌌 [Taylor Swift Instagram Post]. Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/xg07ik/the_making_of_midnights_taylor_swift_instagram/
Booth, P. (2018). A Companion to Media Fandom and Fan Studies (P. Booth, Ed.). John Wiley & Sons, Inc. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119237211
Buchanan, S. (2023, August 7). Fandom, pop music, and reproduction of race–gender inequalities. E-Space.mmu.ac.uk. https://e-space.mmu.ac.uk/id/eprint/632418
Carlin, S. (2022). Taylor Swift’s Midnights: The Biggest Takeaways. Time. https://time.com/6223793/taylor-swift-midnights-album-takeaways/
Carroll, G. (2023). “Oh my god, how did I spend all that money?”: Lived experiences in two commodified fandom communities. Ses.library.usyd.edu.au. https://ses.library.usyd.edu.au/handle/2123/31469
covertlybrowsing. (2023, January 2). What is going on with the midnights era? Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/1011360/what_is_going_on_with_the_midnights_era/
DiBenedetto, C., & Cavender, E. (2022, October 21). Taylor Swift’s “Midnights” is here. Let’s talk about those fan theories. Mashable. https://mashable.com/article/taylor-swift-midnights-album-theories-explained
eastcoastfoliage. (2022, October 29). Can someone please explain to me why Midnights by Taylor Swift is such a big deal? Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/LetsTalkMusic/comments/yga0sw/can_someone_please_explain_to_me_why_midnights_by/
Forslund, E. (2023). Construction of knowledge in online fandom spaces : Sexuality discourse in Taylor Swift fans’ subreddits. In www.diva-portal.org. https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2:1779261
Galloway, K. (2022). Podcasting Taylor Listening Strategies, Fandom, and the Sonic Environments of Taylor Swift Podcasting. https://doi.org/10.1525/jpms.2023.35.4.91
Jenkins, H. (2012). Textual Poachers: Television Fans and Participatory Culture. In Google Books. Routledge. https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=7ZHhRyfJdBAC&oi=fnd&pg=PP2&dq=Jenkins+on+participatory+culture&ots=EcoEkHekSx&sig=0svs9Aj6LgW0-y9OW44Jw2139E8
Magliocca, M. (2023). Communication for Personal Relationships: A Qualitative Study on Taylor Swift’s Music Videos and Message-Design Logics Theory. Scholars Crossing. https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/4915/
Max, J. I. S. D., Vivian, Y. I., Putra, B. A., & Kuncara, S. D. (2023). Transitivity Analysis of Taylor Swift’s Lyrics in Midnights Album. Indonesian Journal of EFL and Linguistics, 279–294. https://doi.org/10.21462/ijefl.v8i2.688
mr_struggle2. (2022, November 27). Is anyone else disappointed by Midnights? Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/z67q7a/is_anyone_else_disappointed_by_midnights/
Rosenblatt, K. (2022, October 21). Taylor Swift’s “Midnights” album release prompts more Tay-spiracies on social media. NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/pop-culture/taylor-swifts-midnights-album-release-prompts-tay-spiracies-social-med-rcna52772
Senior-Muffin-6991. (2023, June 24). Is Midnights anyone’s favorite album? Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/14hz5ng/is_midnights_anyones_favorite_album/
Yahr, E. (2022). Analysis | 2022: The year in review (Taylor’s version). Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/arts-entertainment/2022/12/26/taylor-swift-2022-midnights-ticketmaster/
Z.-side’s Music Reviews. (2022, December 13). Midnights by Taylor Swift | Album Review. Modern Music Analysis. https://medium.com/modern-music-analysis/midnight-ventures-taylors-latest-record-is-a-return-to-the-pop-oriented-sound-of-reputation-and-816f8f4c0bbd
Appendix
Appendix A: Noted thread questioning why Swift’s latest album rollout seemed atypically low-profile. Retrieved from:
https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/z67q7a/is_anyone_else_disappointed_by_midnights/
Appendix B: Post asking ”Is Midnights anyone’s favourite album?” Retrieved from:
https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/14hz5ng/is_midnights_anyones_favorite_album/
Appendix C: music subreddit questioning why “midnight” by Taylor swift is such a big deal Retrieved from https://www.reddit.com/r/LetsTalkMusic/comments/yga0sw/can_someone_please_explain_to_me_why_midnights_by/
Appendix D: User covertlybrowsing expressing disappointment over Taylor Swift’s limited promotion and engagement with her “Midnights” album era. Retrieved from https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/1011360/what_is_going_on_with_the_midnights_era/
Appendix E: user ban_ana_perfect shares Instagram post of Taylor making the “midnights” album. Retrieved from https://www.reddit.com/r/TaylorSwift/comments/xg07ik/the_making_of_midnights_taylor_swift_instagram/?rdt=53098